📍Supreme Court favours the Great Indian Bustard!

 

In a petition filed by the conservationist M.K. Ranjitsinh to protect the critically endangered Great Indian Bustard (GIB) and Lesser Florican from dying by hitting overhead power lines, the Supreme Court delivered a judgement in favour of protecting the birds. What a welcome step!

 

The ruling recognized that the "right to be free from the adverse effects of climate change" is an autonomous, self-determining right. That this right derives from the two fundamental rights granted in the Constitution of India, Article 21 and Article 14.

 

→ Article 21 grants every individual the Right to Life and Personal Liberty. The Supreme Court bench read this to say that  A stable, healthy climate is an essential prerequisite to enjoying a meaningful life.

 

→ Article 14 grants the Right to Equality. The Supreme Court read in this case that Disproportionate climate burdens on vulnerable communities violate equal protection of the laws.

 

The Great Indian Bustard locally called Godawan is the state bird of Rajasthan where it is considered a symbol of pride and grace. It is revered by local communities, especially by the nature loving Bishnois. The Godawan is one of the heaviest flying birds in the world and is a flagship species of the arid and semi-arid grasslands of the Indian subcontinent.

the news: https://www-barandbench-com.cdn.ampproject.org/v/s/www.barandbench.com/amp/story/law-firms/view-point/judicial-responses-to-climate-change-constitutionalising-right-to-clean-environment-and-protection-against-effects-of-climate-change?amp_js_v=0.1&_gsa=1#webview=1&cap=swipe 

📍It's raining Jargon.

It's raining Jargon. Close on the heels of Heatflation, comes Climateflation,. This definition refers to a permanent rise in the cost of living driven by the impacts of climate change and the economic responses to it. 

Coined by the economist Isabel Schnabel in 2022, the term portrays how environmental breakdown and extreme weather turn temporary price spikes into long-term inflation.

Holding up Climateflation are three junior flations:

👉 Carbonflation: Costs resulting from impacts of heatwaves, floods, and droughts that destroy agriculture and infrastructure.

👉 Greenflation: Higher costs associated with transitioning to renewable energy and retrofitting old infrastructure

👉 Fossilflation: price shocks in fossil fuels driven by external dependency, geopolitical conflicts, and energy bottlenecks.

📌 RTI Law Turned On Its Head!

(from the archives)

A combination of intimidation and mindless application of the letter of the law threatens to dissuade citizens from putting the RTI Act to use. And politicians are only happy to offer solutions that further dilute the law's purpose. Suman Sahai and Swati Gola note examples from Chhatisgarh that point to the need for a program for rights literacy.

Recently, BBC News carried a feature reporting the prohibitive cost of obtaining information through the Right to Information (RTI) Act in India. A farmer in Chattisgarh who had asked for information on paddy purchases in his area was given a bill of Rs.1,82,000 for costs that were allegedly incurred for photocopying the official documents relating to the purchases. The documents filled an entire room. In another incident, a resident of Bilaspur district, Chattisgarh was told to pay Rs.75,000 for information he had requested on the positions available for schoolteachers.

The village council official of Bilaspur said that they did not have the money to provide information to people. In Chattisgarh, a person who demands information has to pay Rs.2 for every photocopied page of official documents. Authorities say that ever since the law was passed, the poor have risen to demand information from the government but the government does not have money to supply it. The Chief Minister of Chattisgarh has stated that well-to-do people are using the poor to get information free from the government (the fees are waived for the poor below the poverty line). He urged that the law be changed to allow the officials to examine whether the requested information is useful for the person asking for it.

It is not hard to see that the applicant was seeking the status and availability of the positions for schoolteachers. What, then, motivated him to photocopy the application forms of 9000 candidates, and bill the petitioner for this mindless act?

These incidents should not have happened. They are geared to defeat the purpose of the RTI Act, which is essentially to introduce transparency in governance and to check corruption. These actions can be attributed to one of two reasons. The first, a deliberate attempt to intimidate those seeking information so that misdeeds and corruptions are not exposed. The second, which is far more likely: that there is lack of familiarity with the law and no application of mind to the provisions of law in order to enable people to access information.

• A huge bill has been handed over to a poor farmer whereas it is clearly provided under proviso to S. 7 (6) of RI Act that the fee shall be reasonable and information should be provided for free to persons who are living below the poverty line. Thus the act of State Public Information Officer is in clear contravention of the provisions of the law.
• The information officer is required under S. 7(3) of the RTI Act to intimate the applicant how much it will cost to prove the information alongwith the calculations made to arrive at the amount. He is further required to inform the applicant of his/her right to review the decision regarding the amount of fees charged or the form of access provided as well as the particulars of the appellate authority. Instead of applying his mind, the SPIO has handed over an enormous bill running into lakhs of rupees to a poor farmer. This is in clear violation of the legal provision.
• The law gives ample discretion to the Central or State Public Information Officer under S. 7(9) to assess whether the form in which the information is sought would disproportionately divert the resources of the public authority. Accordingly the SPIO should have sought clarification from the applicant as to what particular information he/she wished to have. He should have facilitated the applicant’s request for information and intervened if the information sought was unclear and would result in bulk copying of documents. Instead of providing a stack of photocopies without application of mind to its relevance and which resulted in avoidable expenditure of public resources, the applicant should have been guided and informed of the expenditure and be given the alternative to inspect the files and file notings and then take the photocopies of only the most relevant portions.
• The claim of the official that the government has no money to provide the information is inadmissible and holds no ground. The cost of photocopying an official document is charged at Rs2/- page, which is not a reasonable amount. Photocopy machines are already installed in government departments and can be used at nominal cost. Even if the photocopying is done at a commercial establishment, the costs vary from 50-75 paise per page at the most.

The proposal of the Chattisgarh government to seek changes in the RTI Act that will allow officials to determine whether the information sought is ‘useful’ to the applicant is absurd, and could be judged to be malafide. The RTI Act was legislated after a great deal of debate and discussion within civil society and with officials and government departments. The result is a consensus legislation, which has at its core good governance to enable development from the grassroots up in a functional democracy. Instead of trying to derail the Act, the Chattisgarh government would do well to educate itself and train its officials to interpret and implement the law so as to achieve its goal.

Providing a stack of non-relevant information and handing over a bill close to two lakh rupees is not only a waste of public resources but appears to be a tactic to deny information and deter others from seeking information from the government. If the intention of the government official was infact to provide relevant information, it is not hard to see that the applicant was seeking the status and availability of the positions for schoolteachers. What, then, motivated him to photocopy the application forms of 9000 candidates for the post, and bill the petitioner for this mindless act?

The objective of the RTI Act is to improve transparency in public working but the incidents mentioned above reveal the resistance of the bureaucracy to open their functioning to scrutiny. They are unwilling to provide information, and when they have to they resort to creating hurdles by senseless application of provisions of the Act. These incidents underline the great need for a public information campaign to engender a rights literacy program so that the public can become aware of its rights and have full knowledge of the legal provisions through which it can exercise its rights.

This article appeared in India Together on 13 June 2006 -https://indiatogether.org/letterlaw-rti/

📍World Rivers Day (27 Sept 26)

Given the way nature is being degraded in the name of “development”, a movement has begun across the world claiming that Nature has Rights like people do. Included in this movement is the backing for the Right of Rivers. 

The Universal Declaration of River Rights says that rivers have :

• The Right to flow unhindered along their natural course.
• The Right to maintain their ecosystem functions and the health of their habitats.
• The Right to maintain and preserve the diversity of their flora and fauna
• The Right to be protected from pollution, and
• The Legal Right to be restored from their damaged state.

On this World Rivers Day, let us affirm the Right of Rivers and commit ourselves to the protection of this life giving resource without which survival on this planet would not be possible.

📍 Space Pharma: Making Drugs in Space

Shooting things into space is no longer just about rockets, satellites and launch vehicles or Chandrayaan and SpaceX and so on. There is a space frenzy and the newest happening thing is Space Pharma – the manufacturing of drugs and medicines in space. Earnings from the space economy are projected to be huge. Market professionals are anticipating that it could surpass $1 trillion by 2040. While settled industries like semiconductors and fiber-optic cables will be the biggest earners, Space Pharma is emerging as a significant player.

A number of precision drugs like monoclonal antibodies, steroids, antibiotics among many others, may now be coming from space. A number of pharmaceutical companies in recent times have been heading straight to the lower orbit of the earth to manufacture medicines. So what is the reason for going all that distance, you may ask, why not continue to produce drugs on earth as always? The answer is Microgravity. Microgravity is the state when the pull of gravity is not very strong since gravitational force gets weaker when objects are far apart. This microgravity condition is very enabling for the pharmaceutical sector as we shall see.

When pharmaceutical products are manufactured on earth, they face challenges from the force of gravity. How? because of a process called sedimentation when heavy particles settle below and smaller, lighter particles float on top. This disrupts the drug synthesis process because the mixture of compounds that goes into making a drug remains uneven. Fluids sink, making the mixture uneven. Unevenly distributed particles in compositions create problems

with dosage.

In space however, there is very low gravitational force, or micro gravity where the distortions created by gravitational force are cancelled. Better drugs can be manufactured in space by taking advantage of the microgravity conditions in low-Earth orbit. This enables the synthesis of more precise complex biological molecules and purer, more uniform protein crystals.

When molecules are more uniform, they become easier to administer to patients, When crystals are a mix of different sizes, small crystals hide in the gaps of larger ones, making the liquid thicker, more viscous. This matters because viscosity determines the efficiency with which patients absorb the medicine. Viscous injectable medicines are painful to administer, when viscosity is lowered, complex mixtures become lighter and less painful to take. 

The United States is the world leader in commercial space-based drug manufacturing and is already establishing supply chains. The US is followed by the UK which is trying to capture a dominant share of the European space-pharma market. Third in line is India a new player in the space-pharma arena.

Serendipity Space is the name of India’s first dedicated Space Pharma start-up operating out of Bhubaneshwar. The company is building satellites to manufacture pharmaceutical compounds in orbit so that drug crystals can be manufactured in microgravity. These will be brought back to produce purer forms of medicines than are possible on Earth. A futuristic, new sector is developing in medicines and it is wonderful to know that India is a major player.

📌 Deforestation On Ground, Afforestation On Paper!

South Asia is among the world’s most climate-vulnerable regions. Rising temperatures, erratic rainfall, droughts and extreme weather are already threatening water, agriculture and food security. The World Bank warns that climate change could sharply reduce living conditions for hundreds of millions of South Asians.

In such a situation, expanding and protecting green cover should be a national climate priority. Yet the CAG’s latest audit of the Green India Mission tells a disturbing story. Against a target of 1.4 million hectares of additional forest cover, only about 0.03 million hectares was achieved between 2015–16 and 2024–25. Resulting into a shortfall of approx. 98% (https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/green-india-mission-fell-short-by-98-in-increasing-forest-cover-cag-11912065). This should ideally be read a 100% only you know.

The Hasdeo-Arand landscape in Chhattisgarh is a particularly stark example. In June 2026, the environment ministry granted in-principle forest clearance for diversion of 1,742.6 hectares for the Kente Extension coal block, followed by environmental clearance later that month. The proposed Great Nicobar Island infrastructure project involves an integrated transshipment terminal, airport, township and associated development across a large area. Government documents record an in-principle approval for diversion of 130.75 sq km of forest land.

Moreover, between April 2023 and March 2026, 71,023 hectares of forest land was approved for diversion to non-forest purposes across the country. The reality it seems is that we are failing to create forests while continuing to sacrifice existing ones. Planting saplings cannot compensate for destroying mature, biodiverse natural forests. Climate policy must begin with protecting the forests we already have.

📌 Climate Impact on Forests!

The rich, natural forests of India were brought under “modern, scientific” forestry by the British in 1864. And with that the Indian tradition of seeing the forest as a community resource to be conserved and used sustainably was jettisoned. In its place came the commercial exploitation of the forest by the colonial rulers. Natural mixed forests used freely by locals for their personal needs and for incomes were replaced by commercial monocultures like teak, pine, and sal which were owned by the British.

Colonial exploitation of the forest was reversed when the Forest Rights Act, 2006 was enacted. This Act recognized that Adivasi and tribal communities as well as other traditional forest dwellers have the legal right to own, collect, use and sell minor forest produce, collectively known as Non-Timber Forest Products (NTFPs) NTFPs include tendu leaves used for rolling bidis, mahua flowers and seeds, wild fruits and nuts, honey, tamarind, medicinal plants, herbs, bamboo and a variety of edible and useful forest products. For Adivasi and other forest-dwelling communities, these products have traditionally been part of their food, livelihoods and everyday lives.

But climate change is beginning to interfere with the seasonal and ecological processes on which these resources depend. A change in rainfall is affecting flowering so availability of Mahua flowers gets affected. Rising temperatures affect fruiting and seed production. Drought can reduce the availability of edible plants and wild fruits. Changes in temperature and moisture also affect major NTFPs such as honey and lac which are significant income sources for the tribal communities and forest dwellers.

These changes are already being felt .The forest may still be standing. Its canopy may even appear unchanged. But if the flowers do not bloom as before, if fruits become scarce, or if seasonal forest produce becomes unreliable, then the forest is no longer the livelihood supporting resource it used to be.