Thursday, July 18, 2019

KIDS GO ON STRIKE TO SAVE CLIMATE

A young girl in Sweden seems to have taken a leaf out of Mahatma Gandhi’s book on Civil Disobedience. Greta Thunberg was 15 last year when she began to bunk school every Friday to sit outside the Swedish Parliament demanding that Sweden do something about climate change. Other school kids in Sweden joined her and they bunk school to sit in protest every Friday in front of their Parliament. Since then, Greta  has inspired children across the world to join the rebellion against extinction of life on the planet. They call it the Extinction Rebellion. Their initial demand was for Sweden, to fulfill the goals of the Paris Ageement on climate change but they are now calling on world leaders to act ‘maturely” on climate change.. On March 14 2019, all of 16 years of age, she was nominated for the Nobel Peace Prize.

At the Paris climate agreement of 2017 , nearly 200 countries committed to limiting global temperature rise to 1.5 degrees Celsius above the temperature of the pre-industrial age. If not 1.5 degrees, then at least to keep the rise  below 2 degrees. But this is not happening. The US , one of the world’s largest emitters of greenhouse gases that are warming the planet has withdrawn from the Agreement and will place no restrictions on itself to reduce emissions.

The heroic and thoughtful actions of this extraordinary student activist have led to a global children’s movement. On March 15 this year thousands of school children from almost 100 countries joined the Children’s Strike in a concerted global action to demand action from world leaders to halt the destruction caused by climate change. From countries as varied as India, South Korea, Australia, France and others in Europe and the US, the world’s children bunked school to get parents and elders to start taking seriously the climate disaster confronting us and to do something about it.

Even Indian children joined the strike, some as young as ten years old. Some NCR schools were supported by their teachers to miss school and collect at the Central Park in Delhi’s Connaught Place to demand a clean environment that would allow them to breathe clean air. Anyone who has lived in Delhi or the National Capital Region (NCR) which  includes Noida and Gurugram, knows that the winter months are a serious challenge because of the toxic air quality.

The children of the NCR joined the global Extinction Rebellion, carrying placards with  slogans like Fridays for Future, because the children’s strike across the world is staged every Friday. Indian school children articulated their demand for “clean air, water and soils for our safe future”  One placard said “ No Saans, No Vote”, telling contestants in the upcoming election to take note of the environment.


Medical advisories are issued to close schools and keep children indoors. Among other things, the cost of air pollution in India is 10 lakh premature deaths every year. This is apart from debilitating illnesses like asthma and cardio vascular disease. All of this leads to reduced quality of life and big financial burdens for the family and the government . India’s cities are some of the most polluted in the world, with Delhi being tagged as by far the most polluted. But it’s not just Delhi, almost all north India cities have filthy air. Jaipur, Varanasi, Lucknow, Mumbai, any city really , is a toxic nightmare.

What is scary is that according to all scientific estimates, even adhering to the goals and targets of the Paris Agreement will not stop Global Warming. There is so much carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases in the atmosphere already that the earth’s temperature will continue to rise even if we stop emissions today. Scientists assess that temperatures will rise from 2.7 to 3.0 degrees for sure. With the US withdrawing from any commitments to cut emissions, its more likely to be a 3 degree rise.

The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) , the global body that tracks climate change, has said that an increase of 1.5 degrees over pre industrial levels will mean extreme weather conditions with floods, droughts and cyclones,  heavy and unpredictable rainfall, heat waves, water shortages , melting glaciers and sea level rise. This will cause havoc. And t2030 is just 11 years away.

So what the children are doing should make the adults sit up and think. No, sit up and panic. Many of the children have responded to adult criticism of their strike, saying if we won’t have a future, then school and education will not matter. The children are fighting for their future, the future of the present civilization. The stakes are very high. Adults have to get the message of the school strikes and make one last effort to save ourselves from ultimate extinction. 

Dr Suman Sahai is a scientist and chairperson of the Gene Campaign




Tuesday, May 14, 2019

PEPSICO AND FARMERS RIGHTS

Suman Sahai

The PepsiCo case is getting curiouser. First the company filed a case against nine Gujarat farmers seeking damages of 1.05 crores from each, for growing potatoes of a variety over which it claimed exclusive rights. This was followed by a furor in the media, unusual since agriculture and farmers are not front page news at the best of times and certainly not in the middle of frenetic campaigning for general elections. Then came the news that PepsiCo was withdrawing the case, rumored as it was , amidst negotiations involving the Gujarat government that was brokering a deal in favor of PepsiCo.

Even as newsprint is being dedicated to analyzing the how and why of the company’s withdrawal, is the sober realization that though the offer for withdrawal was made at a court hearing on 26 April , the company has in fact not withdrawn the case against farmers as yet. So was the declaration that they were withdrawing the case just a jumla ? Was it just buying time to quieten the howls of protest from civil society groups till they were able to work out a deal

After an overkill action against farmers with average land holdings between 1.2 and 1.6 hectare, the company probably realized the PR disaster  of a huge multinational company suing small and marginal farmers for enormous amounts of money. It offered an out of court settlement with conditions saying  that farmers “have to sign an agreement with us to buy the seeds and sell the produce to us. Or, the farmers give an undertaking that they will never use our registered seeds without permission in future. Whatever stock they have at present, should be given to us.”

Why on earth would farmers agree to this bizarre offer ? They have committed no offence. It must be clear that farmers have acted fully within the Farmers Rights granted to them under the Indian law. Contrary to its claim of having an “exclusive” right, PepsiCo only has a Breeders Rights registration for its potato variety under the Protection of Plant Varieties and Farmers Rights Act, 2001 (PPVFRA). Breeders Rights is not an exclusive right, there are many exemptions to it.  

In the Indian legislation, legal rights have been  granted to both Breeders and Farmers. Farmers Rights grants farmers the right to save, use, sow, resow, exchange, share and sell seed of a variety protected under this Act in the same manner as before the coming into force of this Act.  This means that farmers can sell the seed of any variety , even if it has a Breeders Rights registration, for local use as they have always done. Farmers cannot brand this seed with the Breeder’s name,  in this case FC 5.

The Gujarat farmers were not selling any branded seed. They have committed no violation of the law. They can buy seed from other farmers which they have apparently done and they are fully within their rights to cultivate the crop and sell it wherever they like. PepsiCo has  no business insisting the farmer buy seed only from them or that they sell only to them. This is sheer bullying and intimidation.  

Farmers Rights in the Indian legislation was finalized after nearly ten years of negotiations with three different governments and it was discussed by two Joint Parliamentary Committees.  Its structure was finalized by an Expert Committee chaired by the legendary  Dr MS Swaminathan. This author was a member of that Expert Committee and Gene Campaign (of  which the author is chairperson) along with others in civil society campaigned ceaselessly for the rights of farmers in the Indian legislation on seeds. The PPVFRA was enacted by Parliament in 2001 and it is accepted by the WTO-TRIPS as compliant with our international commitments. 

India is the only country in the world to have enacted an Intellectual Property Rights  law on seeds that gives rights to both Breeders and Farmers. Under pressure from the multinational seed industry, every other country has given rights only to breeders which are increasingly seed companies like Monsanto and PepsiCo. 

The Gujarat government that is playing arbitrator in the PepsiCo case must do nothing to jeopardize the farmer’s interest.  The aggrieved farmers should now consider filing a suit for injunction and damages against PepsiCo, damages for the harassment and mental anguish caused and injunction against any further harassment.

Dr Suman Sahai is a scientist and chairperson of the Gene Campaign