Saturday, December 10, 2011

WE NEED A BETTER FOOD SECURITY LAW

Suman Sahai

Despite the proposition that independent India has not had large scale famines, widespread hunger prevails and by all accounts, is growing. As we now know from official data, the majority of the population does not attain the minimum calorie levels for rural and urban areas. According to one estimate almost 87 per cent of the rural population gets less than the rural cut-off of 2400 calories/day, and 64.5 per cent of the urban population gets less than the urban cut-off of 2100 calories/day. India finds itself at the bottom in terms of the HDI rankings. According to the multiple poverty index the levels of poverty in the country are alarming, in the range of 645 million, or 55.4 per cent of the population.


The Indian State Hunger Index (ISHI) found that 12 of 17 states surveyed had ‘alarming’ levels of hunger, with one state having an ‘extremely alarming’ level. Not a single state had ‘low’ or ‘moderate’ hunger levels. Despite this commonality, the ISHI demonstrated high variability in hunger between states. The ISHI enabled global comparisons which showed that several of India’s worst performing states have higher levels of hunger than countries such as Zimbabwe and Haiti. Madhya Pradesh, the worst performing state, ranked just above Ethiopia.


The agrarian crisis
The output of food grains in 2003–04 was still 14 million tonnes below the high level reached in 2000–01. Admittedly the food grain production did go up in the last two years yet the shortfall is still massive. In 2011 there was the announcement of so-called record food grain production which prompted the lifting of the Supreme Court ban on wheat exports. Nevertheless, this increase in production has been limited to the surplus states such as Punjab, Haryana, and Andhra Pradesh whereas the rainfed states suffering from the highest levels of hunger, such as Madhya Pradesh and Jharkhand, have not shared in these increases. On the contrary, the extent of fallow lands is increasing as farmers are unable to farm due to the paucity of productive resources. Given these growth rates and the regional disparities in hunger and agricultural production, it is not surprising that hunger and malnutrition have reached unprecedented levels.
Malnutrition

Today, nearly half of India’s children below the age of three are malnourished and stunted, and 40 per cent of rural India eats only as much food as sub-Saharan Africa. According to the UN’s Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO), India is one among 17 countries where the number of the undernourished decreased in the first half of the 1990s, before increasing in the second half, thus almost completely offsetting the gains made during the earlier part of the decade. The per capita availability of food has declined for the first time since the 1960s. The official National Sample Survey (NSS) of 2000 revealed that three-fourths of India’s rural population and half the urban population did not get the minimum recommended calories. This is confirmed by nutritional and health surveys, which show: more than two-fifths of the adult population suffers from chronic energy deficiency, and a large percentage are at the border of this condition; half of India’s women are anaemic; and half of India’s children can be clinically defined as malnourished (stunted, wasting, or both). It is estimated that half of the Indian rural population, over 350 million people, are below the average food energy intake of sub-Saharan African countries.

Economic reforms in India have led to disinvestment in the agriculture sector. This has adversely affected more than 60 percent of the population which relies on agriculture for its livelihood. Many of the farmers responsible for making India self-sufficient in grain production are themselves facing hunger due to non-remunerative prices and rising input costs, among other factors. The following graphs show how the new agriculture policies have diminished the food availability gains made in the 1980s, resulting in a food availability situation not much better than the early 1950’s.

Fig 1: Food Grain Availability

Source: Directorate of Economics and Statistics, Delhi 2005.
Fig. 1 shows that the 1950s, and up to 1964, the per capita availability of food grains ranged between 140 and 170 kg per annum. The availability dropped drastically in 1967, when it touched 143 kg, and then it increased again. What is noteworthy is the trend between 1979 and 1994, when the per capita availability of food grains ranged between 155 and 180 kg per annum. After 1994, availability declined to 150 kg per annum.

This picture becomes clearer if we mark out the per day availability of food grains as shown in Fig. 2.

Fig. 2 : Per Day Food Availability

Source: Directorate of Economics and Statistics, Delhi, 2005.
Fig. 2 shows that the net per day availability of food grains in India has dipped alarmingly. It is now touching almost the same levels that it had reached in the early 1950s, at less than 450 grams per day per capita. There is a considerable shortfall in the actual requirement and availability of food grains. In the context of the current agrarian crisis, this trend poses a grave danger to communities already afflicted with hunger.

The Food Security Bill
In the backdrop of declining food availability, there have been diverse efforts to tackle hunger. There has been the Public Distribution System (PDS) providing subsidized grain, the Integrated Child Development Scheme (ICDS) and the mid-day meal scheme for school children.

The most recent in this line of efforts to improve the hunger situation, is the National Food Security Bill (NFSB) proposed by the powerful National Advisory Council (NAC). The NFSB is being considered seriously by the government where reception to its contents is mixed at best. Elements in government and out of it have not been unanimously supportive of the Bill. An expert committee headed by C Rangarajan, stated that the entitlements outlined under the NAC draft (90 percent coverage of the rural population and 50 percent of the urban) were not feasible due to unavailability of sufficient food grains. They recommended that the entitlements which were guaranteed for above poverty line (APL) households be discarded and that only below poverty line (BPL) households (as measured by the Tendulkar estimate plus a ten percent margin) be included in the scheme. This would mean a drastic reduction in coverage with only 46 percent of the rural population and 28 percent of the urban included under the ambit of the legislation.

The Agriculture Minister Sharad Pawar has expressed doubt over the large quantity of grain procurement that would be required by the NAC draft and said that the issues raised by the Rangarajan Committee remained ‘pertinent’. Adding to this, the Food Ministry submitted their revised draft legislation days later which was substantially different from NAC’s proposal and decreased both the scope and size of the entitlements. Civil society groups appear divided on the NAC Bill, with some terming it merely a revised form of the PDS.

There are grave problems with the government draft that patterns itself on the draft provided by the National Advisory Council. Primary is its extremely restricted scope. This is not a Bill that attempts to bring about food security, it is only a Bill that offers a different plan to the existing PDS system, to distribute grain. No attention is paid to the most important components of food security, the production of food, its distribution and its absorption by the poor and hungry. Of the three major pillars of food security, food production, food distribution and food absorption, the NAC draft addresses just one. It is actually more a welfare Bill, a ‘dole’ as it were than an effort to tackle the complex problem of food security per se.

Tackling food security will certainly mean treading on influential toes. The conflicts will arise over who will have preferential access to productive resources like land and water. Will Coca Cola get the water for its bottling plant or will farmers get it for their cultivation? Will small farmers in the dry lands get massive investments in creating water bodies to enable them to have a second crop in the winter? The conflicts will be over such things like fertiliser subsidies. Will Punjab, Haryana, Western UP, Andhra Pradesh and Tamil Nadu continue as the principal beneficiaries of the government’s subsidies or will nutrient based subsidy be directed at poor quality soils in rainfed areas that most need intervention, finally get their due? The smallest , most marginal farmers have the worst soils and the least access to water. A Food Security Bill will have meaning only if it tries to swing things in their favour.

The Food Security Bill must tackle the fundamental question of common property resources and the right of access to them. It must be able to speak out against Jatropha plantations on common lands which are conveniently designated as ‘wasteland’. The biofuel produced in the name of clean energy will take away the grazing lands of herders and pastoralists , the place where they can park their livestock because they have no other land. It will take away the source of leafy green vegetables and medicinal plants that the poor rely on.

Just as it will have to tackle the Coca Colas , the Food Security Bill must also take a position against the Adanis, the Reliance lot and all the other conglomerates who are grabbing agricultural lands in the name of SEZs to set up industrial estates ( or just to corner real estate ) India’s most productive lands, the two crop and three crop zones are being snapped up to build urban estates. Where will we grow our food?

The food production part of the Food Security Bill will also have to deal with putting into place our response to ensure food security when faced with climate change. According to the IPCC report, the impact of climate change will be most severe in Africa and South Asia, especially its rainfed areas. We cannot continue behaving as though this is someone else’s problem and even as we debate the finer points of universal versus targeted distribution of food grains , that someone will step in and make the problem go away.

The neglect of rural India continues . There is no technical or financial obstruction to providing sanitation and clean drinking water in mission mode but it still has not been done. Children continue to die of diarrhoea and adults continue to sicken with it , unable to retain the little nutrition they get. There is no reason why this simple intervention has still not been done….
The fact is that to draft a truly comprehensive Food Security Bill and accommodate the logical aspects that belong there, a lot of people will have to be asked to give up some of what is in their bag of goodies. The Food Security Bill clearly fights shy of that .

Questions have also been raised about the manner of drafting this Bill. What kinds of consultations were undertaken? How did the principal stakeholders engage in the process of providing inputs? In what manner were experts and other actors brought on board ? How were the public’s views sought? Has this Bill attempted to be pluralistic representative of other views?


Redrafting a Food Security Legislation
It seems clear that to draft a food security bill, more than just the distribution aspects will have to be addressed. The Bill must include all relevant aspects related to the three major pillars of food security :
• the production (availability) of food,
• the distribution of food
• the absorption of food and nutrition. For this clean drinking water and sanitation are minimum requirements to prevent diarrhoea.

15 comments:

  1. Punjab real estate has never such a bright phase when its realty is next to investors' delight.Apartments in Mohali are the best pick among the investors who want something beyond Chandigarh.3 bedroom flats are wonderful in terms of return on investment in the upcoming years.Cosmopoliatn lifestyle has started gaining footholds and India real estate has onemore addition in its glorioius architecture.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Iridia Horizon Concept
    Iridia Horizon Concept - A living concept that is above the ordinary. Inspired by the grandeur of the 325 acre majestic forest. In the magnificent lap of mother nature.

    Keywords-
    Iridia Horizon Concept

    Contact-
    Horizon Concept Private Limited
    8/13 Jangupra Extension,
    New Delhi, 110014.
    Tel: +91- 1145795775
    Mob: +91-9958110765
    Email: info@horizon-concept.com
    http://iridia.in/iridia-horizon-concept.html

    ReplyDelete
  3. Iridia Noida Sector 86 Call @9015522333

    Iridia offer all types Residential Property in sector 86, Noida expressway, Noida in affordable Price. Iridia Noida, Iridia Horizon Concept

    Keyword-
    Iridia, Iridia Noida Sector-86, Iridia Noida, Horizon Concept Noida

    Contact Us-
    Horizon Concept Private Limited
    B 131, Sector - 2
    Noida (U.P), 201301.
    Tel: +91 1204166161
    Mob: +91 9958110765
    Email: info@horizon-concept.com

    URL-
    http://iridianoida86.in

    ReplyDelete
  4. Iridia Noida | Horizon Eternia | Horizon Concept Pvt. Ltd.

    Horizon Concept Pvt. Ltd. - Presenting - A living Concept that is Above the Ordinary. Inspired by the Grandeur of the 325 Acre Majestic Forest. Iridia Noida, Horizon Eternia.

    Keywords
    Horizon Concept, Iridia Noida, Horizon Eternia

    HEAD OFFICE
    Horizon Concept Private Limited
    B 131, Sector - 2
    Noida (U.P), 201301.
    Tel: +91 1204166161
    Mob: +91-9958110765
    Email: info@horizon-concept.com

    http://horizon-concept.com/

    ReplyDelete
  5. Iridia Noida | Horizon Eternia | Horizon Concept Pvt. Ltd.
    Horizon Concept Pvt. Ltd. - Presenting - A living Concept that is Above the Ordinary. Inspired by the Grandeur of the 325 Acre Majestic Forest. Iridia Noida, Horizon Eternia.
    Keywords
    Horizon Concept, Iridia Noida, Horizon Eternia


    Contact Us :
    HEAD OFFICE
    Horizon Concept Private Limited
    B 131, Sector - 2
    Noida (U.P), 201301.
    Tel: +91 1204166161
    Mob: +91-9958110765
    Email: info@horizon-concept.com

    http://www.horizon-concept.com/

    ReplyDelete
  6. Iridia Noida Sector 86 | Iridia Call@-9015522333

    Welcome to Iridia - Already Delivered, More than 1.7 Mill sq.ft. of Residential Area, 1 Mill sq.ft. of Commercial & 2 Mill sq.ft. of Government Contracts, IRIDIA is a New and Unique Name in Realty Industry.

    Keywords
    Iridia Noida Sector-86, Iridia Noida, Horizon Concept Noida, Iridia.

    Contact Us
    Horizon Concept Private Limited
    B 131, Sector - 2
    Noida (U.P), 201301.
    Mob: +91- 9015522333
    Email: info@horizon-concept.com

    http://iridianoida86.in/

    ReplyDelete
  7. Iridia Noida | Iridia Horizon Concept Call@-9015511222
    Iridia offer all types in sector 86, Noida expressway, Noida. For Best Rate, Iridia Noida, Iridia Horizon Concept. Iridia Presenting affordable all types of Residential Property in sector 86, Noida expressway.

    Keywords
    Iridia Horizon Concept , Iridia Noida

    Contact Us
    Horizon Concept Private Limited
    B 131, Sector - 2
    Noida (U.P), 201301.
    Tel: +91 1204166161
    Mob: +91 9015511222, 9015522333
    Email: info@horizon-concept.com
    http://iridia.in/

    ReplyDelete
  8. Iridia Noida Flats Call@-9015511222
    Iridia Presenting Affordable all Types of Residential Property Iridia Noida, Sector 86 Iridia Horizon Concept in Delhi Ncr Noida.
    Keywords
    Iridia Noida Flats
    Contact Us

    Horizon Concept Private Limited
    B 131, Sector - 2
    Noida (U.P), 201301.
    Mob: +91- 9015511222
    Email: info@horizon-concept.com

    http://iridianoida.net.in/

    ReplyDelete
  9. Iridia Noida | Horizon Eternia | Horizon Concept Pvt. Ltd.

    Horizon Concept Pvt. Ltd. - Presenting - A living Concept that is Above the Ordinary. Inspired by the Grandeur of the 325 Acre Majestic Forest. Iridia Noida, Horizon Eternia.

    Keywords
    Horizon Concept, Iridia Noida, Horizon Eternia

    Contact Us :
    HEAD OFFICE
    Horizon Concept Private Limited
    B 131, Sector - 2
    Noida (U.P), 201301.
    Tel: +91 1204166161
    Mob: +91-9958110765
    Email: info@horizon-concept.com
    http://www.horizon-concept.com/

    ReplyDelete
  10. Iridia Noida Sector 86 | Iridia Call@-9015522333

    Welcome to Iridia - Already Delivered, More than 1.7 Mill sq.ft. of Residential Area, 1 Mill sq.ft. of Commercial & 2 Mill sq.ft. of Government Contracts, IRIDIA is a New and Unique Name in Realty Industry.

    Keywords
    Iridia, Iridia Noida Sector-86, Iridia Noida, Horizon Concept Noida

    Contact Us
    Horizon Concept Private Limited
    B 131, Sector - 2
    Noida (U.P), 201301.
    Mob: +91- 9015522333
    Email: info@horizon-concept.com

    http://iridianoida86.in/

    ReplyDelete
  11. Food security bill will not help poor in anyways but it will create a monsterous scam and ineffciency in maintaining it.....
    Economy of the country will take a hit and political class will not oppose the bill as it might look like they are opposing poor, they right to get things for free...
    http://brainsickthoughts.wordpress.com/2013/05/25/lord-of-corruption-ring-food-security-bill/

    ReplyDelete
  12. Find a Property to Buy in Salasar and search Properties and New Projects on Salasar Enclave in Phulera , Plot in Phulera , Property in Phulera , Plot in Jaipur. It offers you unique opportunity to own property. View us on 333acre.com

    ReplyDelete
  13. Salasar Enclave | Salasar Enclave in Phulera
    Find a Property to Buy in Salasar Enclave and search New Projects and Properties on Salasar Enclave in Phulera with complete property details at 333buildcon.com

    ReplyDelete
  14. Plot in Phulera | Property in Phulera
    Looking for plots in salasar enclave? 333 Buildcon launches residential projects in Jaipur/phulera as salasar enclave. Offering affordable plots, residential apartments and residential plots in salasar enclave. Book your plots in salasar enclave now!

    ReplyDelete
  15. I think, this is really very well information given about Sanjeevni Divine Present Residential Plots With Jaipur Rajasthan. Thanks for given this information here about this blog.
    Lands for Sale in Delhi Road

    ReplyDelete